Taffy Mail – March 2016: Extra Box!

I have a bunch of American friends and I’m always curious about their snacks, mainly because we don’t have most of them here in the UK. It was a big event, and Skype video call, when I had my first Twinkie- which was… revolting but hey. Taffy Mail intrigued all of us, so I was really excited when it came in the mail.

Taffy Mail comes with 3 options; Lite with 4-5 sweets at £7.49 a month. Classic with 10-12 sweets and a can of soda for £14.99 a month. Or Extra with up to 20 sweets, at least one can of soda and at least one premium item like cereal or large packs of Oreos for £24.99 a month! I got the Extra and it came with…

Lay's Stax in Buffalo Wings with Ranch flavour and Deep Dish Pizza flavoured Cheese Curl.

Lay’s Stax in Buffalo Wings with Ranch flavour, being a vegetarian, I passed these on to my family who thought they just tasted like chilli. And there was confusion over buffalo wings since buffalos don’t have wings- It appears they originate from Buffalo.
The other crisps, or as the Americans would say- chips, were Deep Dish Pizza flavoured Cheese Curls. It’s strange how much they actually taste like pizza. Perfect for a sports game with a beer, or just order pizza.

Chewy's in Watermelon and Banana.

Now and Later Chewys in Watermelon and Banana! I can tell you, because they’re now in season and I’ve been eating one or two a day, that the watermelon Chewys do not taste like watermelon. And banana sweets never taste like banana, but this one is pretty close. For 25 Cents (or 18 Pence) they’re not half bad.

Pop Rocks Blue Razz

Pop Rocks are basically the best thing in the world. I only tried them for the first time a couple months ago, videoed by a friend who found the faces I was pulling hilarious, and they’re a pretty good novelty item with the way they fizz. The Blue Razz flavour is tasty too!

Sweets & Sours Skittles

One of my favourite items in the box was the Sweets & Sours Skittles. Give me sour candy any day of the week and I’m there. With Sweet Watermelon, Sour Cherry, Sweet Strawberry, Sour Blue Raspberry and Sweet Orange, I really enjoyed the 5 minutes it took to shove these in my mouth.

Applehead candy

Applehead candies are hard candy and switch through sweet and a little sour as you eat them. Out of the entire box, these were right up there as a favourite and I can’t think of a UK alternative.

SweeTarts Cherry Punch filled ropes

SweeTarts Cherry Punch filled ropes smell like Love Hearts to me, and a strawberry antibiotic medicine from her youth to my mum, but taste sour and tangy. Not half bad!

Cow Tails

Cow Tails come in vanilla and chocolate flavour and are chewy caramel with a cream centre and both came with a weird dusty coating that was off-putting. There was no chocolate hit from the chocolate flavour and the vanilla one tasted of sweeteners. It’s a no from me.


I’ve never heard of Bit’O’Honey but it’s small almond chunks in honey taffy. It was really nice, I didn’t get much almond but the honey taffy was delicious and lasted for ages. I’ll probably pick up a couple next time I’m state-stide.

Payday Bar

“You need to sell those in order to have a Payday!” Michael Scott at his best, throwing one of these peanut caramel bars at business school students. The combination of salty and sweet has never been my favourite but if you are a fan, I can imagine Payday would be a firm favourite with the salted peanuts and caramel mix.

Almond Joy

Almond Joy is a candy bar I’ve wanted to try for ages because I love chocolate, almonds and coconut separately so why not together! Basically a Bounty with an almond on top but I’m the weirdo that was sad when the Celebration boxes did away with Bounty so anything close is all right in my books.

Klondike Caramel Candy

What would you do for a Klondike bar? Or in this case, candy pieces. Keep in mind this covered in a ‘milk chocolate flavouring’, not actually milk chocolate. They kind of tasted like Rolos, but they need to up their chocolate game.

Oreo Brownie

How can you make Oreos better? Make them into a brownie obviously. Oreos are a classic. I’d eat these any day.

Snowballs and Whoppers Strawberry Milkshake

Pink food seems to be a thing over the pond. I love Zombieland so when I saw these (non-hostess) Snowballs, all I could think of was “I like Snowballs!”. Turns out, I don’t. I’m starting to not trust anything American food companies think of as cream. These feel so weird, like a foam pillow or something.
And Whoppers Milkshake malted mint balls in Strawberry are very much like strawberry milkshake in disguise as a Malteaser.

Grape Fanta

The can of soda in this months box was Grape Fanta. I’ve never had grape soda before and I never will again. Lesson learned, Grape Fanta doesn’t taste like grapes.

Limited Edition Mini Trix

And lastly, the premium item of the month is Limited Edition Mini Trix. When I opened these, the first thing I said was- cereal should not be that colour. I found it really gross, but one of my American friends loves them so to each their own.

Our score: 8.0/ 10

Overall, the price is a little high but Taffy Mail is a great box if you love American candy. The variety and the service is great! Some of the food just wasn't for me.

  • Quality of products7
  • Originality7
  • Packaging and delivery10
  • Value for money6
  • Selection of products10

How would you rate Taffy Mail ?

Rating: 3.1/5. From 34 votes.
Please wait...

Taffy Mail

  • American Sweets
  • From £7.49

Hot right now

Hot right now


  • Personal Shopping
  • From £10


Taffy Mail

  • American Sweets
  • From £7.49