Mighty Toothpaste Review: Is the Refillable Dispenser Worth It?

Our reviews are independent of brands. Read about our approach and independence

Cream Mighty toothpaste dispenser held by a bathroom sink

My Mighty toothpaste review in one line: it is a really pleasant way to stop buying plastic tubes. Mighty replaces your toothpaste tube with a refillable dispenser and 50ml refills that go in the compost when they are empty. The dispenser is genuinely lovely to look at, refilling it is simple and works first time, and the Fresh English Mint toothpaste tastes really good. Above all, a pump is far more practical than a tube. The catch is the price, which is higher than a supermarket tube, so here is what it costs, how it works and who it is worth it for.

Mighty at a glance

What to check Mighty
What it is A refillable toothpaste dispenser with an airless pump, plus 50ml home-compostable refills
Toothpaste Fresh English Mint, 1,450ppm fluoride, SLS-free, vegan
Starter pack £16.50 for the dispenser and one refill
Subscription From £20.60 for the dispenser and 3 refills, then £15.60 for 3 refills
Cost per refill £6.50 bought once, £5.20 or less on subscription
Dispenser colours Mint, Sandstone, Blush Pink, Midnight Blue (£10 on its own)
Delivery Royal Mail Tracked 48, £2.99, free from £25 and on a first 3 or 6 refill subscription
Where to buy Mighty’s own site, Boots and Amazon UK

For the full list of plans and policies, see our Mighty profile.

First impressions: a dispenser you want to leave out

I really like the concept, and Mighty has done a superb job on the design. The dispenser is a smooth, matt bottle with a pump on top and a discreet Mighty logo near the base. It is a world away from a squashed tube on the edge of the sink. Mine is the cream one; it also comes in mint, pink and navy if you want one per bathroom.

Mighty Fresh English Mint toothpaste refill next to the cream Mighty refillable dispenser
The 50ml compostable refill and the reusable dispenser it twists into.

The refill is a small white bottle with an aluminium screw cap, printed “Home compostable”. Inside the parcel, a welcome card explains the idea in one picture: an airless pump, a twist-and-lock dispenser that Mighty says is made for travelling, and a refill that breaks down in a home compost. It also quotes a striking figure: 3 billion toothpaste tubes end up in landfill and the oceans every year.

Mighty welcome card explaining the airless pump, twist and lock design and compostable refill
The welcome card sums up the idea: one dispenser, compostable refills.

How refilling works

The refill system is simple to use and it works. There are three steps, printed on an instruction card in the box:

  1. Hold the base and twist the pump head anticlockwise until it comes off.
  2. Remove the cap from the refill and screw the refill into the pump head.
  3. Drop it back into the base and twist clockwise until the nozzle lines up with the Mighty logo.
Mighty instructions showing how to remove the pump head and attach a refill
Three steps on the instruction card: twist off the pump, screw on the refill, lock it back.

It only takes a moment, and you never touch the toothpaste. The empty base is just a sleeve: the refill itself is what connects to the pump, so the dispenser stays clean.

Mighty dispenser opened with the pump head removed next to a capped refill
With the pump head off, the empty base is ready for a refill.

Mighty toothpaste refill screwed onto the dispenser pump head, held in a hand
The refill screws straight onto the pump head.

Mighty refill attached to the pump head being lowered into the dispenser base
Then it drops into the base and twists shut.

When a refill runs out, you repeat the same steps, and the empty one goes in your home compost or general waste.

Using it every day: better than a tube

This is where Mighty won me over. A press puts a neat line of toothpaste straight onto the brush head, whether it is a manual brush or an electric one like my Oral-B. Mighty recommends two pumps per brush.

Mighty dispenser pumping toothpaste onto an electric toothbrush head
A press puts a neat dose straight on the brush head.

It is so much more practical than a tube you are always struggling to squeeze: either too much comes out, or you never manage to finish it.

With the pump, you get the same amount every time, there is no cap to lose and no crusty toothpaste around the opening. And because the refill sits under an airless pump, there is no tube to roll up and cut open at the end to get the last bit out.

The Fresh English Mint toothpaste

I really liked the toothpaste itself. The mint flavour is genuinely good and fresh, and I found its scent really pleasant. Mighty uses real mint oils (field mint and peppermint) rather than synthetic flavouring.

What matters most is what is inside, and here Mighty is a proper fluoride toothpaste, not a “natural” paste that skips the essentials:

  • Fluoride at 1,450ppm, in the form of sodium monofluorophosphate. That is within the 1,350 to 1,500ppm the NHS recommends for adults.
  • Hydrated silica and calcium carbonate to clean and polish.
  • Xylitol, a sweetener that does not feed the bacteria behind tooth decay.
  • Papain, a papaya enzyme that Mighty says helps lift surface stains for natural whitening, without bleach.
  • No SLS (sodium lauryl sulphate), the foaming agent in most mainstream toothpastes. Plant-based cleansers replace it, so it foams less than you may be used to. Mighty says this makes it gentler on sensitive mouths.

It is vegan and cruelty-free, with no parabens, artificial colours or titanium dioxide. The full ingredient list is: glycerin, aqua, hydrated silica, calcium carbonate, sodium monofluorophosphate, xylitol, decyl glucoside, cellulose gum, coco-glucoside, stevioside, papain, Mentha arvensis leaf oil, menthol, Mentha piperita oil, pinene, beta-caryophyllene and limonene.

Mighty says the toothpaste is suitable from age 3. For children aged 3 to 6, the NHS advises a pea-sized amount of toothpaste with at least 1,000ppm fluoride, so use a small amount and supervise brushing.

Is it really better for the planet?

Overall, I think the initiative to cut your impact is a good one, and it is easy to stick with because the product is nicer to use, not more of a chore. The dispenser is designed to be kept for years. The refills are made from a bio-based material that Mighty says is certified home compostable and breaks down without leaving microplastics.

That matters because most toothpaste tubes are made of mixed plastic and aluminium layers. A few brands now make recyclable tubes, but whether your council accepts them varies, and most tubes still end up in general waste. With Mighty, the only thing you throw away is a compostable refill.

Two honest caveats: the refill compost claim assumes you have a home compost (otherwise it goes in general waste), and you are still buying a small bottle every few weeks. It is a real step forward, not zero waste.

How much does Mighty cost?

Option First order Then Per refill
Starter pack, bought once £16.50 (dispenser and 1 refill) £19.50 for 3 refills or £39 for 6 £6.50
Subscription, 3 refills £20.60 (dispenser and 3 refills) £15.60 per delivery £5.20
Subscription, 6 refills £29.60 (6 refills, dispenser free) £29.60 per delivery about £4.93
Extra dispenser £10 none none

Mighty says one 50ml refill lasts one person around four to six weeks, brushing twice a day with two pumps. The subscription sets the frequency from the size of your household: every 3 months for one person on 3 refills, and for 6 refills every 3 months for two people, every 2 months for three and every month for four to six.

For one person on the 3-refill plan, that is £20.60 for the first box, then £62.40 a year, or about 17p a day. It is clearly more than a supermarket tube, which you can buy for a pound or two. You are paying for the dispenser experience, a fluoride paste without SLS and much less plastic. If you are going to try it, the subscription is the way: the first box with the dispenser costs less than the one-off starter pack with three refills, delivery is free on that first order, and you can skip, pause or cancel online.

New customers also get a 30-day money-back guarantee. Note that refill packs cannot otherwise be returned for hygiene reasons unless they are faulty.

Delivery

Mighty ships across the UK and the Channel Islands with Royal Mail Tracked 48. Orders placed before 4pm on a weekday usually leave within 24 hours and arrive in two to three working days. Delivery costs £2.99, or £3.99 for some remote postcodes, and is free from £25 and on a first subscription of 3 or 6 refills.

What other buyers say

On Mighty’s own site, 520 customer reviews average 4.3 out of 5, and 82% of reviewers recommend it. The recent reviews I read praise the toothpaste and how easy the dispenser is to assemble, though one buyer found the pump “a little bit temperamental”.

Who Mighty is for

  • Anyone tired of messy tubes: the pump is cleaner, tidier and gives the same dose every time.
  • People who want to cut bathroom plastic without switching to tablets or powders.
  • Design lovers who want a sink that looks good.
  • Families, as long as you share one flavour: one dispenser per bathroom and a 6-refill plan works well.
  • People who get on badly with SLS, as it is SLS-free while keeping full-strength fluoride.

It is less suited to tight budgets, to anyone who wants a specialist paste (for very sensitive teeth or gum problems, for example) and to people who like a lot of foam. There is only one flavour so far.

My verdict: is Mighty toothpaste worth it?

Yes, if you are willing to pay a little more for a better daily experience and less plastic. Mighty has really worked on the whole thing: the dispenser is beautiful, refilling is simple and efficient, the English Mint tastes great and the pump is far more practical than a tube. The toothpaste is a proper 1,450ppm fluoride formula, so you are not trading protection for good intentions. Start with a subscription to get the dispenser cheaply and free delivery, and adjust the frequency once you know how fast you use a refill.

Frequently asked questions

Mighty toothpaste: your questions answered

Is Mighty toothpaste any good?

Yes. I liked the English Mint taste and found the pump dispenser much more practical than a tube. It is a full fluoride toothpaste (1,450ppm) without SLS, and it averages 4.3 out of 5 from 520 customer reviews.

How long does a Mighty refill last?

Mighty says one 50ml refill lasts one person around four to six weeks, brushing twice a day with two pumps.

How do you refill a Mighty toothpaste dispenser?

Twist off the pump head, screw the new refill into it, drop it back into the base and twist until the nozzle lines up with the logo.

Does Mighty toothpaste contain fluoride?

Yes, 1,450ppm, within the range the NHS recommends for adults (1,350 to 1,500ppm).

Is Mighty toothpaste SLS-free and vegan?

Yes. It contains no sodium lauryl sulphate, parabens, artificial colours or titanium dioxide, and it is vegan and cruelty-free.

Are Mighty refills really compostable?

Mighty says its refills are made from a bio-based material certified home compostable that leaves no microplastics. Put them in a home compost or, if you do not have one, in general waste.

Can children use Mighty toothpaste?

Mighty says it is suitable from age 3. The NHS advises a pea-sized amount for children aged 3 to 6, with supervision, and spitting rather than rinsing.

Is Mighty good for travelling?

Mighty says the twist-and-lock dispenser is designed for travel.

Four Mighty toothpaste dispensers in mint, sandstone, blush pink and midnight blue beside a toothbrush pot
Mighty logo

Mighty

  • Refillable mint toothpaste
  • From £13.2

All Subscription Boxes editorial team

About Michaël Maarek

Founder of AllSubscriptionBoxes. I'm passionate about cooking, photography, travel and above all Subscription Boxes, I am always looking for new discoveries that I like to share with those around me.

Questions & reviews

Have a question about this box?

Share a question, opinion or experience. Our team reads every message and will reply.

Start the conversation

Your email is never displayed. First-time contributions are reviewed before publication.

Mighty logo

Mighty

  • Refillable mint toothpaste
  • From £13.2

Latest reviews & news